Judging by Tears of the Kingdom's Metacritic score, it's an instant GOTY contender

The Breath of the Wild sequel is already Metacritic

metacritic on X: With 306 exact score predictions lodged, our users on FB/TW predict that The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom will have a Metascore of 95.1 (Must-Play): Check

Wario64 on X: no surprise, Zelda Tears of the Kingdom is reviewing as one of the best games based on review scores / X

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Review (Nintendo Switch) - Official GBAtemp Review

What Do You Think of the Final Fantasy 16 PS5 Demo?

Tears of the Kingdom is filled with perfect reviews on Metacritic; the strongest contender for the GOTY of 2023

Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom is the highest-rated game of the year

The Battle for Game of the Year in a Superb 2023 Begins on Monday

Six Months Later, Tears Of The Kingdom's Sense Of Wonder Is Still Unmatched

The Game Awards 2022 - Wikipedia

TotK] Tears of the Kingdom nominated for Most Anticipated Game! : r/zelda